Former 
Mr. Gay New Jersey's



Junior Corbin Sinister - 2019
Contest not held - 2018

Miguel Blaze - 2017

Felipe Love Santos - 2016

Rey Sinister Sky - 2015

Emanuel Sky - 2014

Joey Sky - 2013

Willito Rivera - 2012

Jose Vega - 2011
 Chocolate X Vizcaya - 2010
Chocolate X Vizcaya - 2010 
 
Miguel Allure - 2009
Miguel Allure - 2009
Tyson Anyae - 2008
Tyson Anyae - 2008
   
Neo - 2007
Neo Hall Richards - 2007
Johnny V - 2006
Johnny V. - 2006
   
Troy - 2005
Troy Schrantz - 2005
Alan Joseph - 2004
Alan Joseph Fortenberry - 2004
   
Kole Michaels - 2003
Kole Michaels - 2003
Dartanyan Johnson - 2003
Dartanyan Johnson - 2002
   
Sebastian Armonte - 2001
Sebastian Armonte - 2001
Michael Karan - 2000
Michael Karan - 2000
   

Will Milian - 1999
 

Formers:
Miss Gay NJ
Mr. Gay NJ
Miss Gay NJ At-Large

Mr. Gay NJ MI
Miss Gay NJ Latina
Miss Gay NJ Newcomer