Former 
Miss Gay New Jersey Newcomers


Miss Gay New Jersey Newcomer 2019
Oprah Tunity

Miss Gay New Jersey Newcomer 2018
Peaches Blaze

Miss Gay New Jersey Newcomer 2017
Jazal Jazalien

 

Formers:
Miss Gay NJ
Mr. Gay NJ
Miss Gay NJ At-Large

Mr. Gay NJ MI
Miss Gay NJ Latina
Miss Gay NJ Newcomer