Former 
Miss Gay New Jersey Latina's



No Contest for 2019 or 2018



Samantha Chanel Famouz - 2017



Ebony J'adore Sinister Sky - 2016


Sasha Sinister
- 2015

Formers:
Miss Gay NJ
Mr. Gay NJ
Miss Gay NJ At-Large

Mr. Gay NJ MI
Miss Gay NJ Latina
Miss Gay NJ Newcomer