Former 
Miss Gay New Jersey's



Jazal Jazalien - 2019
Contest not held - 2018

Lady Keyonta - 2017

Daniella Mendez - 2016

Lea Sky - 2014

Kristy Blaze - 2015

Victoria Courtez - 2013

 Sabrina Rey Fox - 2012
Verona Sky Blake - 2010
Verona Voulure DeMornay
- 2010

 Leona Chanel - 2011
Veronica Vizcaya - 2009
Veronica Vizcaya
- 2009
Nikky Sky - 2008
Nikky Sky
- 2008
Aaliyah 
      Kiara Demur - 2007
Aaliyah Kiara Demur - 2007
Lady Marisa - 2006
Lady Marisa - 2006
Melina - 2005
Melina - 2005
Empress Vizcaya - 2004
Empress Vizcaya - 2004
Ashley Blake - 2003
Ashley Blake - 2003
Alexis Milian - 2002
Alexis Milian - 2002
Tony Mona - 2001
Tony Mona - 2001
Morgan Wells - 2000
Morgan Wells - 2000
Rebecca Finn - 1999
Rebecca Finn - 1999
Dana Terrell - 1998
Dana Terrell - 1998
Taryn Blake - 1997
Taryn Blake - 1997
Cheyenne - 1996
Cheyenne - 1996
Jesse Volt - 1995
Jesse Volt - 1995
Kitty Fouche - 1994
Kitty Fouche - 1994
Danee Russo - 1993
Danee Russo - 1993
Mary Margret - 1992
Mary Margret - 1992
Vanessa Diamond - 1991
Vanessa Diamond - 1991
Tyler Alyxander - 1990
Tyler Alyxander - 1990
Berrie Lyndon - 1989
Berrie Lyndon - 1989
Robin Wayne - 1988
Robin Wayne - 1988
Paris St John - 1987
Paris St John - 1987
Chantel Curtis - 1986
Chantel Curtis - 1986
Stephanie Turner - 1985
Stephanie Turner - 1985
Michael Joel - 1984
Michael Joel - 1984
Delilah Sampson - 1983
Delilah Sampson - 1983
Steve Miller - 1982
Steve Miller - 1982

Formers:
Miss Gay NJ
Mr. Gay NJ
Miss Gay NJ At-Large

Mr. Gay NJ MI
Miss Gay NJ Latina
Miss Gay NJ Newcomer