Former 
Miss Gay New Jersey At-Large's


 
Michelle Ramirez - 2016

Davida Sky - 2015 
 
 Bella Sky - 2014
No contest for 2012 

 Rachael Ann Summers - 2011
 
Lydia F@mouz La Madrid - 2010
Lydia F@mouz - 2010
Nikki La Rue Vizcaya - 2009
Nikki La Rue Vizcaya - 2009
   

Juliza Blake Alezae - 2007
Juliza Blake Alezae - 2007

Julie Vuitton - 2008
Julie Vuitton - 2008
  
Nexxis Lexxis - 2006
Nexxis Lexxis - 2006
Cee Mour Cox - 2005
Cee Mour Cox - 2005
  
Jasmine Finn - 2004
Jasmine Finn - 2004
Twinkle Montgomery - 2003
Twinkle Montgomery - 2003

Mystique Solaye - 2002



Formers:
Miss Gay NJ
Mr. Gay NJ
Miss Gay NJ At-Large

Mr. Gay NJ MI
Miss Gay NJ Latina
Miss Gay NJ Newcomer